How Withhold Release Orders (WROs) Work

In the realm of international trade, the United States Customs and Border Protection (CBP) plays a pivotal role in ensuring that goods entering the U.S. market meet certain standards. One of the most critical tools in this process is the Withhold Release Order, issued when CBP suspects that goods are made with forced labor. Issuing a WRO is a serious step, impacting not only the specific shipments but potentially the entire supply chain of a company. Understanding how WROs work, the process involved, and the steps importers must take to ensure compliance is vital for businesses engaged in U.S. imports. In this article, we will explore the WRO process in detail, providing insights into its stages, compliance requirements, and ongoing enforcement.

Investigation and Evidence Gathering

The WRO process begins with CBP's investigation into suspected forced labor practices. CBP uses multiple sources, including global trade data, The WRO process begins with CBP's investigation into suspected forced labor practices. CBP uses multiple sources to gather evidence of forced labor, including reports from whistleblowers, non-governmental organizations (NGOs), industry watchdogs, and media outlets. The agency also collaborates with international labor organizations and conducts field research to identify regions or companies at higher risk for forced labor. In this context, supply chain risk management plays a critical role in identifying vulnerabilities within the supply chain that could expose companies to forced labor risks.

The evidence gathered by CBP typically includes indicators such as:

• Excessive Overtime: Forced overtime occurs when workers are required to work beyond legal working hours, often without fair compensation or breaks. Employers exploit workers by extending shifts with no additional pay, sometimes up to 12-16 hours a day, contributing to physical exhaustion and compromised working conditions.

• Debt Bondage: Debt bondage traps workers in exploitative situations by requiring them to work to repay inflated or manipulated debts. Common among migrant workers, this practice forces employees into perpetual labor to pay off recruitment fees or living expenses. The debt is often artificially inflated, creating a cycle of dependence.

• Withheld Wages: Employers withhold wages as a control mechanism, preventing workers from leaving or resisting exploitation. Wages may be delayed or entirely withheld to force workers to stay. This tactic is used to trap workers in financial dependence, making them unable to quit or seek better conditions.

• Restricted Worker Mobility: Restricting worker mobility involves limiting workers' ability to leave their workplace or return home. Employers may confiscate passports or use physical threats to prevent workers from leaving. This control tactic confines workers to the employer’s control, often isolating them from their families and communities.

CBP is committed to ensuring that only cases with credible, substantiated evidence result in a WRO, maintaining high standards of accountability. According to a 2023 report, CBP issued 202 WROs, reflecting its commitment to addressing forced labor in global supply chains.

Issuance of the WRO

Once CBP has sufficient evidence of forced labor, it issues a WRO to prevent the importation of the affected goods. This order blocks the entire shipment from entering the U.S. until the importer proves that forced labor was not involved in its production. A WRO can target specific goods, companies, or even entire regions depending on the scope of the evidence.

For example, in 2022, CBP issued a WRO against cotton from China's Xinjiang region due to evidence of forced labor practices linked to the Uyghur population. Such actions have a profound impact, as the U.S. is one of the largest importers of goods, with imports totaling over $2.7 trillion in 2023. The issuance of a WRO can significantly disrupt trade operations, particularly for companies relying on products from high-risk regions or suppliers.

WROs are not permanent but remain in place until CBP is satisfied that the company or supplier has taken sufficient steps to eliminate forced labor from its supply chain. This process can take several months, during which importers must work diligently to provide the necessary documentation to clear their goods for entry.

Importer Response and Compliance Process

When an importer’s shipment is subject to a WRO, they must provide substantial documentation to demonstrate compliance with U.S. labor laws. The burden of proof falls on the importer, who must show that forced labor was not involved in the production of the detained goods. Key documents required include:

• Third-Party Audits: Independent audits are conducted by respected organizations like the Fair Labor Association (FLA) or Social Accountability International (SA8000). These audits evaluate labor conditions and ensure ethical practices, such as fair wages and safe working environments. They provide an impartial review of an importer’s supply chain to verify that no forced labor is involved.

• Worker Contracts and Payment Records: Importers must provide clear documentation, including contracts and payment records, showing that workers were paid fairly and worked within legal limits. This includes proof of proper wages, overtime compensation, and adherence to legal working hours, ensuring that labor standards are met and preventing exploitation.

• Supply Chain Mapping: A comprehensive supply chain map outlines every step of production, from raw material extraction to the final product. It helps CBP trace the origins of goods and ensure that no forced labor was involved at any stage. The map provides transparency, helping verify that the supply chain remains free from unethical labor practices.

• Certifications: Certifications from recognized organizations, such as SA8000 or FLA, demonstrate that the supply chain complies with labor laws and ethical standards. These certifications provide third-party validation of a company’s commitment to ethical labor practices and help prove that forced labor has been eliminated from the supply chain.

In 2023, the U.S. government reported that approximately 70% of WROs issued resulted in the importers providing sufficient documentation, leading to the removal of the order and the release of the goods. However, in cases where the documentation is inadequate, the goods will be denied entry, and the importer may face heightened scrutiny for future shipments.

Ongoing Monitoring and Enforcement

The WRO process does not end once an order is lifted. CBP continues to monitor companies and suppliers previously implicated in forced labor practices to ensure they remain compliant with U.S. labor standards. If repeated violations occur, the importer may face stricter penalties and prolonged scrutiny. In 2022 alone, the U.S. Customs and Border Protection conducted 1,200 follow-up investigations related to forced labor, focusing on industries such as apparel, electronics, and agricultural products. Companies found to have violated WRO terms face reputational damage, potential fines, and long-term damage to business relationships.

Ongoing monitoring often involves the use of supply chain analytics to ensure continued compliance with ethical labor standards. As global supply chains become more complex and diverse, leveraging advanced analytics can help companies proactively identify risks and mitigate potential issues before they escalate into full-scale investigations or WROs. This is particularly important with the UFLPA, which mandates that companies prove their goods are free from forced labor from the Xinjiang region.

To explore our solution for Upstream and Downstream Supply Chain Mapping

Click Here

Conclusion

The WRO process is a crucial part of the U.S. government's efforts to combat forced labor in international trade. By taking proactive measures to investigate, issue, and enforce WROs, CBP plays an essential role in protecting workers' rights and ensuring ethical practices within global supply chains. For importers, understanding the intricacies of the WRO process is vital. Failure to comply with U.S. regulations can result in severe consequences, including shipment delays, reputational harm, and lost business opportunities.

In a landscape where forced labor continues to be a significant global issue, businesses must stay vigilant in ensuring that their supply chains are free from exploitation. Compliance not only helps avoid the disruptions caused by WROs but also contributes to a more ethical and sustainable global economy. With the increasing emphasis on corporate responsibility, companies must prioritize supply chain transparency, collaboration, and continuous improvement in their supply chain practices. By doing so, they not only safeguard their business interests but also contribute to the broader effort of eradicating forced labor from global trade.